Florida Keys buyers signed 78 new single-family contracts in October 2026, down from 109 a year ago. In the same month, the median sale price jumped, and those two facts belong in the same conversation. Below, single-family and condo/townhouse are broken out side by side, each compared to October 2025.
October 2026 at a Glance: Fewer buyers signed contracts in October than a year ago, on single-family homes and condos alike, and supply kept shrinking. Median prices climbed for both, but sellers did not get any more of their asking price, so the higher medians more likely reflect which homes sold than a rise in values.
Single-Family Homes: October 2026 vs. October 2025

Florida Keys Single-Family Statistics, October 2026 vs. October 2025. Source: SunStats, Monroe County.
Supply kept tightening on the single-family side. Active listings and new listings both ran 12% below last October, so fewer owners are putting homes on the market and fewer homes are sitting for sale.
Buyer commitments slowed even more than supply did. Pending inventory fell 13%, and new contracts fell harder still. Closings rose 5.1% to 104, but closings mostly reflect contracts written in earlier months.
Then there is the median. At $1,285,000 it sits 28% above October 2025. The average sale price rose a far more modest 7.2%, and sellers received a median 91.5% of their original list price, compared with 91.9% a year ago. If values were climbing that fast, sellers would be getting closer to their asking price, not slightly further from it. The jump more likely reflects which homes happened to close in October than a broad rise in values.
Key Market Highlights: Florida Keys Single-Family, October 2026
| Metric | October 2026 | Change vs. Oct 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| Active Inventory | 830 | Down 12% |
| Pending Inventory | 104 | Down 13% |
| Closed Sales | 104 | Up 5.1% |
| New Listings | 190 | Down 12% |
| New Pending Sales | 78 | Down 28% |
| Median Sale Price | $1,285,000 | Up 28% |
Condo/Townhouse: October 2026 vs. October 2025

Florida Keys Condo/Townhouse Statistics, October 2026 vs. October 2025. Source: SunStats, Monroe County.
Condo and townhouse closings took the biggest hit on the condo side, and new contracts fell nearly as hard, so the slowdown shows up at both ends of the deal.
Active condo listings fell 20%, even with a small rise in new listings, so condo buyers have fewer units to choose from than a year ago.
The condo median rose 26% to $860,000 on just 27 sales, while sellers received a median 91.4% of original list price, down from 95.0% a year earlier. Condo sellers are giving up more room in negotiation, not less, so the higher median more likely reflects which units sold than a rise in condo values.
Key Market Highlights: Florida Keys Condo/Townhouse, October 2026
| Metric | October 2026 | Change vs. Oct 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| Active Inventory | 287 | Down 20% |
| Pending Inventory | 29 | Down 9.4% |
| Closed Sales | 27 | Down 27% |
| New Listings | 59 | Up 3.5% |
| New Pending Sales | 23 | Down 23% |
| Median Sale Price | $860,000 | Up 26% |
What the October Numbers Point To
For two months running, the single-family story was tight supply with more homes under contract than a year earlier. The September 2026 Florida Keys report showed pending inventory up 18%. October broke that run. Pending inventory turned lower, and contract activity slowed for condos too.
Single-family homes are also taking longer to find a buyer, with a median 108 days to contract compared with 100 a year ago. Condos went under contract faster, at 95 days compared with 103. For a longer view, the October 2025 Florida Keys report showed residential listings rising at that time. This October, they are lower than a year ago.
My read is that the Keys are heading into the winter season more measured than a year ago. Buyers are taking more time and negotiating, while supply stays lean. Well-priced homes should keep selling, but pricing to what buyers are actually paying matters more than the headline medians.
A Word to Buyers
October gave buyers more room than a year ago. Fewer people are writing contracts, single-family homes are taking longer to go under contract, and sellers are not getting any more of their asking price than a year ago. Meanwhile, the buyers who closed in October are already settling in for the winter season.
If you have been waiting on the fence, a slower month is a good time to look closely and negotiate with confidence. Browse the newest Florida Keys homes for sale, or see how buying in the Florida Keys works before you start.
A Word to Sellers
Your competition is still thin, with fewer homes and condos for sale than a year ago. What changed in October is the buyer. Fewer are signing, and single-family homes are taking longer to go under contract. That puts the weight on presentation and price. A home that shows well and is priced to recent closed sales stands out when buyers are being choosy.
One way to stand out: my certified home program, with a pre-listing inspection, issues handled before buyers find them, and a home warranty that goes with the sale. See how selling works in today’s Florida Keys market.
Local Market Reports
Want the numbers for one area? The October 2026 local reports break out single-family and condo/townhouse statistics the same way.
- Key Largo Real Estate Market: October 2026
- Islamorada Real Estate Market: October 2026
- Marathon Real Estate Market: October 2026
- Key West Real Estate Market: October 2026
Looking between Marathon and Key West? Browse current Lower Keys homes for sale.
Florida Keys Real Estate: Frequently Asked Questions
Why did the Florida Keys median sale price jump in October 2026?
The single-family median rose 28%, but across all residential property types the median rose 17% to $1,055,000, and sellers received a median 91.1% of their original list price, down from 92.4% a year earlier. A higher median with no gain in the share of asking price more likely points to a different mix of homes selling than to a jump in what any one home is worth.
Are fewer buyers signing contracts in the Florida Keys?
Yes. Buyers signed 111 new residential contracts across the Florida Keys in October 2026, compared with 149 in October 2025, a 25% decline. Pending inventory, the homes under contract but not yet closed, fell to 148 from 165.
How many homes were for sale in the Florida Keys in October 2026?
There were 830 single-family homes and 287 condos and townhouses for sale in October 2026. Single-family supply was down 12% and condo supply down 20% from October 2025, leaving buyers fewer choices in both categories.
How many homes sold in the Florida Keys in October 2026?
Residential closings across the Florida Keys totaled 141 in October 2026, down 2.1% from 144 a year earlier. Single-family closings rose to 104, condo and townhouse closings fell to 27, and the remaining 10 were other residential property types.
About this report: Figures come from Florida Realtors SunStats residential data for Monroe County, which covers the Florida Keys from Key Largo to Key West. Each figure compares October 2026 with October 2025, with single-family homes and condos/townhouses reported separately. Countywide numbers can differ from any one community, so see the local market reports above for Key Largo, Islamorada, Marathon and Key West.