Some homes earn their reputation through location alone. Others earn it through what someone was willing to put into them. This one does both.
28 Mutiny Place, Buccaneer Point, Key Largo. Photo courtesy Maris Delgado, LoKation Real Estate.
28 Mutiny Place sits on a gated third-of-an-acre lot in Buccaneer Point, one of Key Largo's most recognized bayside communities near Mile Marker 98. The setting is a private saltwater lake framed by tropical fish, exotic birdlife, and the kind of sunsets that stop a conversation. The home itself has been fully updated.
View details and current price for 28 Mutiny Place.
The Outdoor Life This Home Was Built For
The exterior is where this property makes its clearest statement. A custom tiki hut with a wrap-around bar and built-in grill, an oversized rainfall outdoor shower, and a massive wrap-around balcony with unobstructed lake views make this yard as livable as the interior. Launch kayaks and paddleboards from your own backyard. Watch great white herons work the shoreline from the balcony. The fully gated grounds offer exceptional privacy, with abundant parking for a boat trailer, RV, or guests.
View of the saltwater lake from the wrap-around balcony.
The outdoor kitchen is not an afterthought. This is a dedicated cooking and entertaining space designed for the way people actually live in the Keys - outside, most of the time.
Inside: Updated Without Apology
Travertine tile floors run through the main living level. The open-concept layout is drenched in natural light. The kitchen centers on a massive quartz island with bar seating, high-end stainless appliances, and sleek modern cabinetry. It's the kind of kitchen that works for a private dinner or a full house of guests equally well.
The bathrooms are genuine showstoppers. Floor-to-ceiling hand-painted tile walls, premium fixtures, and bold modern design that reads anything but builder-grade.
The big-ticket items are handled: brand new impact windows and doors, newer roof, newer AC system, all new ductwork and insulation. A whole-home water softener system rounds it out. This is not a home where the buyer inherits deferred maintenance.
Want to see this property in person? 28 Mutiny Place is easy to show, but you'll want to get on the schedule early. Click here to book a private walkthrough.
The Water Side of the Equation
Buccaneer Point occupies a bayside peninsula where Florida Bay and Buttonwood Sound meet. Boaters moving between the two bays navigate Baker's Cut at the northern tip, one of the more recognizable landmarks in the Upper Keys.
Aerial view of Buccaneer Point, Key Largo.
The north lake at Buccaneer Point is a private enclosed saltwater lake. No through-traffic, no boat wakes - just still water with wildlife and sky. It is one of the more peaceful settings you will find in Key Largo real estate.
For residents who want on-water access, the neighboring Pirate's Cove association offers an optional annual membership for around $250 per year. That gets you access to their community boat ramp and bay access without the bayfront premium baked into the purchase price.
The Investment Case
Rentals are allowed at 28 Mutiny Place with a 28-day minimum. The fully updated interior, outdoor living space, lakefront setting, and location within a well-established community make this a strong candidate for seasonal vacation rental income. Furniture is negotiable, which means a buyer could be operational quickly.
Fully renovated homes with current storm protection in Buccaneer Point are not common. This one is move-in ready on day one.
About This Listing
28 Mutiny Place is listed by Maris Delgado of LoKation Real Estate. This post was produced by Jim Signor - Florida Keys Real Estate with the listing agent's permission.
To schedule a showing, visit schedulejim.com.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is 28 Mutiny Place in Buccaneer Point, Key Largo?
28 Mutiny Place is a fully updated 3-bedroom, 2-bath CBS elevated home on a saltwater lake in Buccaneer Point, one of Key Largo's most distinctive bayside communities. The property sits on 15,545 square feet with expansive lake views, a tiki hut outdoor kitchen, wrap-around balcony, and optional boat ramp access through the neighboring Pirate's Cove association.
Is Buccaneer Point on the ocean or bay side of Key Largo?
Buccaneer Point is on the bayside of Key Largo near Mile Marker 98, occupying a peninsula that divides Florida Bay from Buttonwood Sound. Homes face either open bay water or one of two saltwater lakes within the community.
Do Buccaneer Point homeowners have boating access?
The north lake in Buccaneer Point is enclosed with no direct boating access. However, residents can purchase an optional annual membership to the neighboring Pirate's Cove association for approximately $250 per year, which provides access to their community boat ramp.
Is 28 Mutiny Place in Buccaneer Point a good vacation rental?
28 Mutiny Place allows rentals with a 28-day minimum rental period. The fully updated interior, outdoor living space, and lakefront setting make it a strong candidate for seasonal vacation rental income when not in personal use.
What is the asking price for 28 Mutiny Place in Key Largo?
28 Mutiny Place is listed at $1,499,000. Prices on active listings can change - check the current listing for the latest status and price.