Point Pleasant Homes Near Mile Marker 99.5

Point Pleasant sits on the bayside of Key Largo near mile marker 99.5, in the middle of the island. The name fits. Life here moves between the bay, the sailing club, and a short run to dinner, with very little time spent in the car.

See Point Pleasant Homes for Sale

Homes in Point Pleasant are either directly on the bay or non-waterfront. Bayfront owners get wide-open water out the back door and a front-row seat to Key Largo sunsets. Non-waterfront owners keep the bay and the club within an easy walk, often at a meaningful savings compared to buying on the water.

Central, Convenient, and on the Bay

Groceries, restaurants, and errands along the Overseas Highway are minutes away, so everyday life stays simple. Then you come home to a quiet bayside street instead of the highway.

The Upper Keys Sailing Club is next door. Whether you race on weekends, take a lesson, or just like watching the boats come in at sunset, the club becomes part of the neighborhood.

Point Pleasant sits beside Lazy Lagoon and Buttonwood Shores. For more bayside waterfront options a short drive south, see Buccaneer Point, or browse all Key Largo real estate.

Selling in Point Pleasant? A central bayside location is one of the easiest stories to tell a buyer. I help sellers back that story up with my certified home program: a pre-listing inspection, issues addressed before buyers see them, and a home warranty. Learn more about selling with me.

Want to see what has sold on the bay and off it? The Point Pleasant market report lists active homes, pending contracts, and two years of closed sales. Homes for sale today are shown below.

Frequently Asked Questions

Thinking about Point Pleasant? Contact Jim Signor or call 305-394-4449.