Islamorada Homes for Sale Under $1 Million

Finding a home in Islamorada under $1 million gets harder every year. This page shows listings across Plantation Key, Windley Key, Upper Matecumbe Key, and Lower Matecumbe Key priced under $1 million, updated in real time from the MLS.

Inventory is limited and moves quickly at this price point. Create a free account to set up a personalized search with instant alerts so you hear about new listings before most buyers do. Or contact Jim Signor at 305-394-4449 to get set up directly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are there homes for sale in Islamorada under $1 million?

Yes, though options are limited and inventory at this price point has shrunk steadily as values have risen.

Which islands in Islamorada have homes priced under $1 million?

Plantation Key tends to have the most availability under $1 million. Listings on Windley Key, Upper Matecumbe Key, and Lower Matecumbe Key appear occasionally.

How do I get notified when a new Islamorada listing under $1 million hits the market?

Create a free account and set up a saved search with instant alerts. You'll be notified as soon as a matching listing hits the MLS.

How often are these Islamorada listings updated?

Listings are pulled directly from the Florida Keys MLS and updated every five minutes.

Affordable Islamorada Homes

101 Orange Ln, Islamorada $735,000

Solid Concrete Home on Plantation Key! Live the Islamorada lifestyle from this solid concrete home in a desirable Plantation Key subdivision. The home is ground level ...

4 Beds
3 Baths
621604 MLS

202 Hibiscus St, Islamorada $760,000

Charming CBS home located in Plantation Key Colony, situated on a corner lot and in an X flood zone. Offering over 1,300sf of living space, this 2 bedroom / 2 bath home f...

2 Beds
2 Baths
621446 MLS

148 Tequesta St, Tavernier $999,000

Build Now! Purchase price does not include the built home. This price includes the Canal Front Lot, Building Allocation from the Village of Islamorada, approved by the ...

3 Beds
2 Baths
621391 MLS

100 Iroquois Dr Unit Unit 5, Islamorada image

100 Iroquois Dr Unit Unit 5, Islamorada $999,999

Embrace the ultimate island lifestyle in this beautifully renovated waterfront home on Lower Matecumbe Key, featuring 32 ft of private dockage and effortless ocean access...

3 Beds
3 Baths
621101 MLS

207 Hibiscus St, Tavernier $695,000 ▼

BEAUTIFUL PLANTATION KEY COLONY 2BR-2BA CBS Block Construction with a Brand New Metal Roof, featuring a PRIVATE COMMUNITY BOAT RAMP with a Low Voluntary $250 Yearly Fee a...

2 Beds
2 Baths
620947 MLS

115 Fontaine Dr, Tavernier $650,000 ▼

ONE OF THE LOWEST PRICED HOMES IN THE VILLAGE OF ISLAMORADA! Charming Home in a desirable Plantation Key Subdivision! This well-maintained Sheffield Steel home offers e...

2 Beds
2 Baths
620881 MLS

149 Pueblo St, Tavernier $750,000 ▼

More Space Than the Tax Records Reflect! This charming Tavernier home offers much more than meets the eye. While the tax records reflect a 2-bedroom home, the enclosed...

4 Beds
2 Baths
620736 MLS

84961 Old Hwy Unit LOT 27, Islamorada image

84961 Old Hwy Unit LOT 27, Islamorada $899,000

Memories begin here. Tucked along the ocean's edge and offering the kind of lifestyle buyers spend years searching for, this one-of-a-kind oceanfront retreat delivers the...

1 Beds
1 Baths
620039 MLS

156 Monroe Dr, Tavernier $949,000 ▼

Rare opportunity to own a half-acre corner parcel in the heart of Plantation Key. With an existing structure already in place, the property offers the flexibility for an ...

3 Beds
2 Baths
620010 MLS

148 Iroquois St, Tavernier $999,000 ▼

Spacious 4 bed, 3 bath home in the desirable Indian Mound neighborhood on Plantation Key. Sitting on two lots totaling about 11,000 sq ft, there's plenty of privacy and e...

4 Beds
3 Baths
619796 MLS

178 Coral Ave, Tavernier $745,000 ▼

Recently renovated and leased through June 2027, this 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home delivers modern updates with classic Keys living -- and comes with a tenant already in pl...

4 Beds
3 Baths
619243 MLS

110 E Ridge Rd, Islamorada $575,000 ▼

FINANCING OPPORTUNITY -- ASSUMABLE VA LOAN AT 4.9%! The existing VA loan may be assumable by a qualified buyer. Buyer does NOT have to be a Veteran. Loan assumption is su...

3 Beds
2 Baths
619040 MLS

84961 Old Hwy Unit 18, Islamorada $849,900 ▼

Beautiful Atlantic Ocean views surround this newer concrete home featuring an open-concept floor plan with 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. Tastefully furnished with a coastal...

2 Beds
2 Baths
618847 MLS

.

Address Search