Are there gated communities in Key West?

Key West has a limited number of gated and access-controlled communities. The island's dense historic development pattern leaves little room for the large gated subdivisions common in mainland Florida but several notable planned and managed communities exist within and immediately adjacent to Key West offering varying levels of security, amenities, and HOA oversight.

This page is informational and reference-only. It is not a listings page and does not include property search results.

Quick answer

  • General answer: yes, Key West has gated and access-controlled communities but options are limited compared to mainland Florida
  • Most notable options: Truman Annex in Old Town and Key West Golf Club on Stock Island
  • Character: Key West gated communities tend to be smaller and more urban than mainland gated subdivisions
  • HOA fees: gated communities in Key West carry higher HOA fees reflecting security, amenities, and shared infrastructure costs
  • Rental rules: vary by community - verify directly with each HOA before purchasing with income intent
  • Buyer profile: appeals to buyers seeking security, managed common areas, and newer construction within a Key West area location

Truman Annex

  • Truman Annex is a planned residential community developed on former US Navy land in the heart of Old Town Key West
  • Features newer construction townhomes and single family homes within a gated and managed environment
  • Located adjacent to the Harry S. Truman Little White House and within easy walking distance of Old Town attractions
  • HOA fees cover security, common area maintenance, and community amenities
  • Truman Annex properties are priced at a premium reflecting the Old Town location and managed community character
  • Short-term rental rules within Truman Annex should be verified directly with the HOA as policies can change

Key West Golf Club

  • Key West Golf Club is a gated residential community located on Stock Island immediately adjacent to Key West
  • The community is built around an 18-hole public golf course and offers a mix of single family homes, townhomes, and condos
  • Considered part of the Key West market by most buyers and agents despite its Stock Island address
  • HOA fees cover golf course maintenance, community amenities, and common area upkeep
  • Key West Golf Club offers more affordable entry points than Truman Annex while still providing a gated community environment close to Key West
  • Rental rules within Key West Golf Club should be verified with the HOA before purchasing with income intent

What buyers should consider in Key West gated communities

  • HOA fees can be substantially higher than non-gated properties and should be factored into total ownership cost
  • Rental restrictions vary by community and must be verified before purchasing with income intent
  • Resale market within smaller gated communities can be more limited due to smaller buyer pools
  • Community rules and lifestyle fit should be evaluated alongside property characteristics and location

More Florida Keys real estate questions

Return to: Florida Keys Real Estate Guides  |  Jim Signor - Florida Keys Real Estate